Who Moderates The Social Media Giants? A Call To End Outsourcing

June 2020
Content moderation and consequences
In our latest report on the social media industry, we look at how the major platforms handle the problem of content moderation: deciding what remains on their sites and what should be removed. Despite the centrality of this task—without it, the platforms would be inundated by harmful content—the social media companies outsource content moderation to third-party vendors. The report examines the consequences of this marginalization of a core element of the social media business model, including how content moderation has played out during the coronavirus pandemic.
Removing Harmful Content
One consequence of the outsourcing and marginalizing of content moderation has been the failure to provide adequate review of hate speech and other material that can spark animosity and violence in developing countries. Focusing on Facebook as a case study, the report describes the role of social media in sparking unrest in Myanmar, India, Sri Lanka, Indonesia, and Ethiopia—and explains how the company says it has recognized this shortcoming and begun to address it.

Related
See allOnline Safety Regulations Around The World: The State of Play and The Way Forward – A Resource Guide
Our new resource guide breaks down and analyzes 26 online platform regulations around the world across 19 jurisdictions, and offers a blueprint for future regulation of the online space consistent with human rights standards and constitutional principles.
Conscience Incorporated
In his new book Conscience Incorporated, Michael Posner, director of the Center for Business and Human Rights, offers practical strategies and bold reforms to help businesses align profitability with ethical responsibility.
Feedback from: Working Group on Gaming and Regulation at NYU Stern Center for Business and Human Rights
The multi-stakeholder working group on gaming and regulation, launched in September 2024, brings together industry, civil society, and regulators to advance informed, constructive global regulation for a healthy and responsible online gaming ecosystem.